本文通过构建投贷联动模式中企业、风投机构与商业银行三方演化合作博弈模型,分析了最优解的形式以及影响各方最优策略的决定因素。研究发现:第一,若企业融资成本下降或企业退出融资的成本上升,则企业倾向参与融资,且与财务成本相比,企业预期对博弈决策的影响更大;第二,当企业控制权随企业创新收益的分配结构适度调整时,有利于三方合作的达成,但控制权过度转移则会抑制合作的达成;第三,政府补贴有利于强化银行参与融资合作,政府对不参与融资的银行进行适度惩罚有利于提高银行的审慎性,但过度惩罚会抑制最优解的形成。
By constructing a tripartite cooperation evolutionary game model of enterprises, venture capital institutions and commercial banks in the investment-loan linkage model, this paper analyzes the form of the optimal solution and the determinants that affect the optimal strategies of all parties. It has found that firstly, if the financing cost of an enterprise falls or the cost of withdrawing financing rises, the enterprise tends to participate in financing, and compared with the financial cost, the enterprise's expectation has a greater influence on the game decision-making. Secondly, when the enterprise control right is adjusted moderately with the distribution structure of enterprise innovation income, it is beneficial to the tripartite cooperation. However, the excessive transfer of control right will inhibit the cooperation. Thirdly, Government subsidy is conducive to strengthening banks' participation in financing cooperation, and moderate punishment by the government for banks that do not participate in financing is conducive to improving Banks' prudence, but excessive punishment will inhibit the formation of optimal solutions.
[1] 顾雷雷,李建军,彭俞超.内外融资条件、融资约束与企业绩效——来自京津冀地区企业调查的新证据[J].经济理论与经济管理,2018(7):88-99.
[2] 迟宪良. 中小企业融资困境与对策研究[D].长春:吉林大学,2007.
[3] 陈燕萍. 科技型中小企业融资模式的研究[D].南宁:广西大学,2017.
[4] 袁天荣,刘为.基于契约理论的风险投资双边道德风险研究[J].财会通讯,2013(21):76-78.
[5] 胡敏翔.促进风投支持实体经济须立法和政策“双轮驱动”[N]. 中国经济时报,2019-05-15(005).
[6] 中国银行业协会商业银行投贷联动研究课题组,杨再平,白瑞明,张亮,张晨.探索商业银行投贷联动新模式——英国“中小企业成长基金”启示与借鉴[J].中国银行业,2015(7):18-30.
[7] 王晓玲. 科技类企业投贷联动融资模式研究[D].兰州:兰州大学,2019.
[8] Jensen M C,Meckling W H.Rights and Production Functions: An Application to Labor-managed Firms and Codetermination[J].The Journal of Business,1979(4):469-506.
[9] 孟亮,王唯伊,马宏大.科创企业不同融资模式的作用差异化数理分析——基于投资者与科创企业的双边效益最大化视角[J].北方经贸,2019(4):129-131.
[10] Hirshleifer J,Coll J C M.What Strategies Can Support the Evolutionary Emergence of Cooperation?[J].Journal of Conflict Rresolution,1988(2):367-398.