本文通过计算1991年—2019年我国财政的可持续性K值发现,我国已连续多年出现财政不可持续的情况。通过对财政赤字货币化与财政的可持续性、经济增长和通货膨胀的实证分析发现:第一,财政不可持续的情况会加快财政赤字货币化进程,而财政赤字货币化在促进经济增长的同时也提高了通货膨胀率,但促进和提高的效果都在减弱;第二,财政赤字货币化能够提高财政的可持续性,尤其是在经济增长率和通胀率较高、赤字较少的阶段;第三,财政赤字货币化必须在一定的前提条件下实施才能有效。因此,我国实行财政赤字货币化应该保持适度性,发挥其在降低财政风险、促进经济增长、提高财政可持续性方面的积极作用。
In view of the feasibility of fiscal deficit monetization, this paper calculates the K value to measure the fiscal sustainability, which shows that China has been experiencing unsustainable fiscal situation for many years. By analyzing the possible positive and negative effects of fiscal deficit monetization, this paper makes an empirical analysis of the relationship among fiscal deficit monetization, fiscal sustainability, economic growth and inflation, it is found that unsustainable fiscal situation will push up the degree of fiscal deficit monetization. Deficit monetization promotes growth and increases inflation rate, however, the promotion and improvement effect are weakening. The monetization of fiscal deficit can improve the fiscal sustainability, especially in the stage of high growth rate and inflation rate and less deficit. Moreover, the monetization of fiscal deficit can reduce the deficit within a certain range with the increase of inflation rate, which indicates that the effective implementation of fiscal deficit is conditional. Therefore, the implementation of fiscal deficit monetization in China should maintain moderation, and give full play to the advantages of reducing fiscal risks and promoting economic growth.
[1] 刘尚希,盛松成,伍戈,余永定,张明,张斌.财政赤字货币化的必要性讨论[J].国际经济评论,2020(4):9-27+4.
[2] 赵建. 国际比较视角下的财政赤字货币化[J].新金融,2020(8):15-18.
[3] 贾康,张晶晶.财政赤字货币化的“真问题”和“落脚点”[J].探索与争鸣,2021(1):42-49+177.
[4] 李成威,景婉博.财政政策与货币政策的有效协同模式:赤字货币化[J].经济与管理评论,2021(2):107-113.
[5] 周皓. 中国结构性的宏观经济政策可以对财政赤字货币化说“不”[J].探索与争鸣,2021(1):17-20.
[6] 刘学智. 财政赤字货币化的思想逻辑及适用环境[J].新金融,2020(10):9-14.
[7] 李礼辉. 财政赤字货币化应慎行[J].新金融,2020(7):8-10.
[8] 孙国峰.现代货币理论的缺陷——基于财政视角[J].国际经济评论,2020(5):92-101+7.
[9] Epstein G A.What is Wrong with Modern Money Theory?A Policy Critique[M].New York:Palgrave Macmillan,2019.
[10] 兰德尔·雷.现代货币理论[M].张慧玉,等,译.北京:中信出版社,2016.
[11] Bossone B.The Monetization of Fiscal Deficits:What is It Exactly?[EB/OL].https://www.the street.com/economonitor/financial-markets/monetization-fiscal-deficits,2020-04-30.
[12] Bartsche,Boivinj,Fishers,et al.Dealing with the Next Downturn:From Unconventional Monetary Policy to Unprecedented Policy Coordination[EB/OL].https://www.suerf.org/policynotes,2020-09-07.
[13] 刘孝斌,钟坚.中国会爆发公共债务危机吗——基于财政可持续性条件视角[J].广东财经大学学报,2018(6): 43-57.