“扶贫羊”悖论——基于资产型贫困陷阱

doi:10.16716/j.cnki.65-1030/f.2021.04.002

新疆财经 ›› 2021,Issue (4): 16-26.doi: 10.16716/j.cnki.65-1030/f.2021.04.002

“扶贫羊”悖论——基于资产型贫困陷阱

楚新元¹, 卢爱珍², 仇韪³

1.新疆财经大学金融学院,新疆乌鲁木齐 830012;
2.新疆财经大学期刊编辑部,新疆乌鲁木齐 830012;
3.新疆财经大学丝路经济与管理研究院/公共管理学院,新疆乌鲁木齐 830012

收稿日期:2020-11-06 出版日期:2021-08-25 发布日期:2021-08-17
作者简介:楚新元（1985—）,男,经济师,博士研究生,研究方向为区域经济、金融学;卢爱珍（1965—）,女,教授,博士生导师,研究方向为金融理论与保险;仇韪（1987—）,男,助理研究员,讲师,经济学博士,研究方向为产业经济学。
基金资助:
新疆财经大学研究生科研创新项目“新疆经济杠杆率水平的测算、风险评估及其对经济增长的影响研究”（XJUFE2019B001）; 新疆财经大学科研基金项目“‘脱实向虚’视阈下新疆产业升级与投融资模式优选研究”（2020XYB003）

Paradox of "Poverty Alleviation Sheep"—Based on the Perspective of Asset-based Poverty Trap

Chu Xinyuan, Lu Aizhen, Qiu Wei

Xinjiang University of Finance and Economics,Urumqi 830012,China

Received:2020-11-06 Online:2021-08-25 Published:2021-08-17

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 本文利用CFPS2010年—2018年家庭追踪调查数据,基于“负收入增长概率”构造检验统计量来检验我国农村地区是否存在资产型贫困陷阱。结果表明：我国农村家庭不存在资产型贫困陷阱,主要原因是农村家庭资本产出弹性的持续性增长以及不同富裕程度家庭的技术水平无显著差异。当存在资产型贫困陷阱时,以“扶贫羊”为代表的无偿援助确实是一种高效的扶贫方式,但在生产要素边际报酬递减规律的作用下,物质资产的投入只能产生短期效应。因此疫情当下,为抑制返贫应优先考虑增加农村家庭的生产性资产和自用性资产,找到内生性致贫原因,为实现持续性脱贫和乡村振兴打下坚实基础。

关键词: “扶贫羊”悖论, 资产型贫困陷阱, 农村家庭收入水平, 负收入增长概率, 资本产出弹性, 乡村振兴

Abstract: This paper uses CFPS 2010-2018 household tracking survey data to construct statistics based on the "probability of negative income growth" to verify whether there is an asset-based poverty trap in rural China. The test results show that there is no poverty trap in rural China, and the elasticity of rural household capital output continues growth and the insignificant difference in the technical level of families with different levels of wealth are the reasons why the poverty trap does not exist. When there is an asset-based poverty trap, the gratuitous aid represented by "poverty alleviation sheep" is indeed an efficient way of poverty alleviation. However, when this strategy is applied to the actual situation in rural China, under the influence of the law of diminishing marginal returns of production factors, the input of material assets will become relatively unimportant and can only show short-term effects. At the moment of the epidemic, from the perspective of curbing the return to poverty in the short term, priority should be given to increasing the production assets and self-use assets of rural households. Sustained poverty alleviation and rural revitalization also need to find endogenous causes of poverty.

Key words: Paradox of "Poverty Alleviation Sheep", Asset Poverty Trap, Rural Household Income Level, Probability of Negative Income Growth, Capital Output Elasticity, Rural Revitalization

中图分类号:

F304.4

楚新元, 卢爱珍, 仇韪. “扶贫羊”悖论——基于资产型贫困陷阱[J]. 新疆财经, 2021, (4): 16-26.

Chu Xinyuan, Lu Aizhen, Qiu Wei. Paradox of "Poverty Alleviation Sheep"—Based on the Perspective of Asset-based Poverty Trap[J]. Finance & Economics of Xinjiang, 2021, (4): 16-26.

参考文献

[1] Sachs J.The End of Poverty:Economic Possibilities for Our Time[J].European Journal of Dental Education,2008(12):17-21.
[2] Easterly W.The Big Push Déjà Vu:A Review of Jeffrey Sachs's the End of Poverty:Economic Possibilities for Our Time[J].Journal of Economic Literature,2006(1):96-105.
[3] Barrett C B,Garg T,McBride L.Well-Being Dynamics and Poverty Traps[J].Annual Review of Resource Economics2016(8):303-327.
[4] Barro R J,Sala-i-Martin X.Economic Growth[M].Cambridge:The MIT Press,2004.
[5] Azariadis C,Stachurski J.Poverty Traps[J].Handbook of Economic Growth,2005(1):295-384.
[6] Barrett C B,Carter M R.The Economics of Poverty Traps and Persistent Poverty:Empirical and Policy Implications[J]. Journal of Development Studies,2013(7):976-990.
[7] Bloom D E,Canning D,Sevilla J.Geography and Poverty Traps[J].Journal of Economic Growth,2003(4):355-378.
[8] Lybbert T J,Barrett C B,Coppock S D L.Stochastic Wealth Dynamics and Risk Management Among a Poor Population[J].The Economic Journal,2004(498):750-777.
[9] Barrett C B,Marenya P P,Mcpeak J,et al.Welfare Dynamics in Rural Kenya and Madagascar[J].Journal of Development Studies,2006(2):248-277.
[10] Adato M,Carter M R,May J.Exploring Poverty Traps and Social Exclusion in South Africa Using Qualitative and Quantitative Data[J].Journal of Development Studies,2006(2):226-247.
[11] Carter M R,Little P D,Mogues T,et al.Poverty Traps and Natural Disasters in Ethiopia and Honduras[J].World De- velopment,2007(5):835-856.
[12] Janzen S A,Carter M R.After the Drought:The Impact of Microinsurance on Consumption Smoothing and Asset Protection[J].NBER Working Papers,2019(3):651-671.
[13] Thomas A C,Gaspart,Frédéric.Does Poverty Trap Rural Malagasy Households?[J].World Development,2015(3): 490-505.
[14] Quah D.Galton's Fallacy and Tests of the Convergence Hypothesis[J].Scandinavian Journal of Economics,1993(4):427-443.
[15] Bianchi M.Testing for Convergence:Evidence from Non-parametric Multimodality Tests[J].Journal of Applied Econometrics,1997(4):393-409.
[16] Carter M R,Barrett C B.The Economics of Poverty Traps and Persistent Poverty:An Asset-based Approach[J]. Journal of Development Studies,2006(2):178-199.
[17] You,Jing.Risk,Under-investment in Agricultural Assets and Dynamic Asset Poverty in Rural China[J].China Economic Review,2014(2):27-45.
[18] 解垩.农村家庭的资产与贫困陷阱[J].中国人口科学,2014(6):71-83+127-128.
[19] 周力,孙杰.气候变化与中国连片特困地区资产贫困陷阱[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),2016(5):55- 64+155.
[20] 边恕,冯梦龙,孙雅娜.中国农村家庭资产贫困的测量与致因[J].中国人口科学,2018(4):54-67+127.
[21] 袁航,吕梦敏,刘景景,毕怡琳.中国农户贫困陷阱:争议与解答——基于2004—2012年农村固定观察点数据的分析[J].经济评论,2018(3):155-164.
[22] 朱烈夫,吕梦敏,袁航.消费平滑假说检验:对农户贫困陷阱争议的解答[J].农村经济,2018(2):59-64.
[23] 周迪,王明哲.返贫现象的内在逻辑:脆弱性脱贫理论及验证[J].财经研究,2019(11):126-139.
[24] 李小云,苑军军. 脱离“贫困陷阱”——以西南H村产业扶贫为例[J].华中农业大学学报(社会科学版),2020(2):8-14.
[25] Arunachalam R,Shenoy A.Poverty Traps,Convergence,and the Dynamics of Household Income[J].Journal of Development Economics,2017(2):215-230.
[26] Banerjee A V,Newman A F.Occupational Choice and the Process of Development[J].Journal of Political Economy, 1993(2):274-298.
[27] Galor O,Zeira J.Income Distribution and Macroeconomics[J].The Review Economic Studies,1993(1):35-52.
[28] Dasgupta P,Debraj R.Inequality as Determinant of Malnutrition and Unemployment:Theory[J].The Economic Journal, 1986(12):1011-1034.
[29] Beegle K,De Weerdt J,Dercon S.Migration and Economic Mobility in Tanzania:Evidence from a Tracking Survey[J]. Review of Economics and Statistics,2011(3):1010-1033.

“扶贫羊”悖论——基于资产型贫困陷阱

Paradox of "Poverty Alleviation Sheep"—Based on the Perspective of Asset-based Poverty Trap

PDF

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 9

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价

[1]	胡承晨, 张帆, 毛丰付. 区域导向型扶贫政策的减贫绩效及作用机制——基于全国832个国家级贫困县数据[J]. 新疆财经, 2022, 0(2): 17-28.
[2]	陈维青, 唐亚菲. 企业参与精准扶贫可以防范系统风险吗?[J]. 新疆财经, 2022, 0(2): 59-69.
[3]	张永奇, 单德朋. 互联网使用对农户家庭金融投资的影响及作用机制——来自CFPS2018的证据[J]. 新疆财经, 2021, 0(4): 5-15.
[4]	柴国俊, 董葆茗, 杨在军. 就业抑或创业：乡村振兴视角下农业经营主体比较研究[J]. 新疆财经, 2021, 0(3): 25-35.
[5]	向洁, 胡青江, 闫海龙. 中国31个省区市财政支农对农业经济增长的空间效应和门槛特征研究[J]. 新疆财经, 2021, 0(1): 17-30.
[6]	杨红丽, 辛瑞, 王云魁. 我国连片特困区普惠金融精准扶贫策略探析[J]. 新疆财经, 2020, 0(4): 15-23.
[7]	李娟伟, 张小倩. 农村居民异质性社会资本对性别收入差距的影响——基于2015年CGSS的经验证据[J]. 新疆财经, 2020, 0(3): 40-52.
[8]	徐建玲, 储怡菲, 顾浩丰. 农户风险偏好、风险认知与水稻生产环节外包决策——基于江苏省水稻种植户的调查[J]. 新疆财经, 2019, 0(6): 37-50.
[9]	张琰飞, 魏昕伊. 精准扶贫视角下乡村旅游企业经营模式创新——基于多案例研究[J]. 新疆财经, 2019, 0(5): 52-61.